The Challenge and Opportunity of Small Church Discipleship
Small churches play a vital role in the Kingdom of God. Yet they face distinct challenges in developing strong discipleship pathways. With limited financial resources, smaller volunteer bases, and often bi-vocational pastors who are stretched thin, small churches may struggle to create structured systems for spiritual growth. Additionally, cultural expectations sometimes push smaller congregations to mimic larger churches’ programs, leading to frustration and burnout. Small group discipleship is a key to vital, healthy churches.
However, these challenges also create unique opportunities. The close-knit nature of small churches fosters deep, authentic relationships, the very soil in which discipleship flourishes. Small group discipleship offers a highly effective, flexible, and personal approach. This dynamic aligns perfectly with the relational strengths of smaller congregations. By focusing on intentional, Spirit-led small group models, small churches can develop vibrant pathways for discipleship. As a result, these pathways can multiply leaders, strengthen faith, and organically grow the church.
The Biblical Foundation for Discipleship Pathways
The Great Commission (Matthew 28:19-20): Jesus’ final command, given before ascending into heaven, was a clear directive. Make disciples of all nations. This commission serves as the central mandate for all churches, regardless of their size and scope.
Discipleship is not optional but is the primary mission of the church. Involving both evangelism and ongoing teaching to foster obedience to Christ’s commands.
The Model of Jesus (Relational & Reproducible): Throughout His ministry, Jesus demonstrated a relational approach to discipleship. He invested deeply in a small group of followers, teaching them through both formal instruction and personal example. This model was designed to be reproduced as His disciples, in turn, discipled others. Creating a multiplication effect that continues to this day.
The Early Church (Acts 2:42-47): The church described in Acts 2 exemplified the practical outworking of discipleship. Characterized by devotion to the apostles’ teaching, fellowship, shared meals, prayer, generosity, and daily community life. This simple, reproducible pattern fostered deep spiritual growth and ongoing multiplication as the Lord added to their number daily.
The Role of the Holy Spirit (Acts 1:8): The empowering presence of the Holy Spirit is essential to effective discipleship. Jesus promised His disciples that they would receive power from the Holy Spirit to be His witnesses. This same power enables believers to live transformed lives, overcome spiritual obstacles, and boldly share their faith, making Spirit-empowered discipleship possible.
The End Goal (Colossians 1:28): The ultimate aim of discipleship is spiritual maturity. Paul expressed this clearly, stating that his ministry sought to present everyone fully mature in Christ. Discipleship is not merely about knowledge acquisition but about shaping lives. Lives that reflect the character, mission, and priorities of Jesus. In turn, producing fully devoted followers who live out their faith in every area of life.
Read Chad’s Blog Post: How to Cast Vision That Inspires Change Without Division
Why Small Group Discipleship Works in Small Churches
Small group discipleship offers unique advantages that naturally fit within the structure of small churches, thanks to the one-on-one opportunities it provides.
- Relational Strength: Small churches are typically built on close relationships. Members know one another personally, creating a strong foundation of trust and accountability essential for effective discipleship. These relationships foster openness, vulnerability, and genuine care, leading to profound spiritual growth.
- Leadership Development: In small church contexts, it’s easier to identify, train, and mentor new leaders. The smaller scale allows pastors and existing leaders to invest deeply in a few emerging leaders, providing hands-on experience and personalized coaching that prepares them to guide others in their discipleship journey.
- Flexible Structure: Small group discipleship can be easily adapted to fit the rhythms of a smaller congregation. Groups can meet in homes, at the church, or in informal settings, and can adjust their schedules to meet the availability of participants. This flexibility helps maintain consistency even amidst busy schedules.
- High Accountability: With fewer people, it’s easier to maintain personal accountability in small groups. Members can share life challenges, prayer needs, and spiritual goals in an intimate setting where follow-up and encouragement are natural parts of the group dynamic.
- Reproducibility: Small group discipleship models can be replicated and multiplied without requiring complex infrastructure. As new leaders are developed, additional groups can be launched, allowing the church’s discipleship efforts to expand organically and sustainably.
5 Key Elements of a Discipleship Pathway for Small Churches
- Clear Spiritual Growth Stages: Establishing well-defined stages of spiritual growth enables individuals and leaders to understand their current position and identify areas for improvement. These stages may include exploring faith, establishing foundational beliefs, growing in spiritual disciplines, engaging in ministry, and eventually leading and discipling others. Each stage should have clear teaching, practices, and accountability to foster intentional growth.
- Simple, Reproducible Small Group Model: The small group structure should be simple enough to be easily multiplied as new leaders emerge. This includes regular Bible study, prayer, personal sharing, and accountability. Keeping the format consistent but flexible allows for easy training of new leaders and ensures that every group functions with the same core purpose and values.
- Leadership Development Pipeline: As disciples grow, they should be intentionally developed into leaders who can disciple others. This pipeline includes identifying potential leaders, offering ongoing training, mentoring them in real ministry contexts, and gradually entrusting them with leadership responsibilities. Investing in leader development ensures a steady stream of capable leaders to sustain the discipleship pathway.
- Consistent Communication and Encouragement: Clear and regular communication from church leadership helps align the entire congregation around the discipleship pathway. Encouraging testimonies, updates on group progress, and celebrating spiritual growth help maintain enthusiasm and momentum for the process.
- Spirit-Empowered Dependence: Every element of the discipleship pathway must be saturated with prayer and reliant on the Holy Spirit’s work. While strategies and structures are essential, true transformation happens through the Spirit’s power. Leaders and participants must continually seek God’s guidance, wisdom, and empowerment as they pursue spiritual growth together.
Read Chad’s Blog: Overcoming Resistance: Shepherding People Who Fear Change
Overcoming 4 Common Small Church Barriers
- Lack of Resources: Many small churches operate with limited financial and material resources. This makes it challenging to purchase curriculum, hire staff, or implement complex programs. However, effective discipleship often requires more intentionality than money. Utilizing free or low-cost Bible study materials, leveraging volunteer leaders, and focusing on relational ministry can overcome these limitations and foster meaningful discipleship growth.
- Leader Shortage: Small churches may feel they lack enough qualified leaders to oversee discipleship groups. The solution lies in developing a culture that recognizes and nurtures leadership potential. Rather than requiring formal qualifications, pastors can train willing, faithful members to serve as facilitators. These leaders can learn to guide discussions, pray, and encourage participants, allowing leadership to grow organically.
- Fear of Change: Change often brings resistance, particularly in smaller, close-knit congregations with established traditions. Leaders must gently cast vision, communicate the biblical mandate for discipleship, and share success stories that demonstrate the benefits of change. Gradually implementing small groups with a clear purpose and celebrating early wins helps reduce fear and foster openness to new discipleship models.
- Overburdened Pastor: Many small church pastors carry multiple responsibilities, leaving little time for direct oversight of every discipleship group. To avoid burnout, pastors must focus on equipping others to lead. By training and empowering group leaders, pastors shift from personally leading every group to providing oversight, encouragement, and support, allowing the discipleship pathway to flourish without exhausting pastoral capacity.
Read Chad’s Blog Post: Mentoring Future Leaders in the Church: Benefits, Challenges, and Candidates
6 Practical First Steps to Launch a Discipleship Pathway
- Pray and Cast Vision: Begin with earnest prayer, seeking God’s guidance and wisdom for the discipleship process. Clearly articulate to the congregation why discipleship matters, using biblical teaching to connect hearts to the mission. Casting a compelling vision helps create unity and anticipation as the church steps forward.
- Select Initial Leaders: Identify spiritually mature individuals who exhibit character, teachability, and a heart for investing in others. These initial leaders don’t need to be experts but should have a willingness to grow and shepherd others with humility and care.
- Equip and Train Leaders: Provide comprehensive yet concise training that equips leaders with the necessary tools to facilitate small group discussions, foster spiritual growth, and effectively manage common group dynamics. Offer ongoing support, mentoring, and resources to help them grow in confidence.
- Start Pilot Groups: Launch a few initial groups as a pilot phase. Use these groups to test the format, gather feedback, and refine your approach. The goal is to work out any challenges before expanding further.
- Evaluate and Adjust: After a set period, evaluate the progress of the groups. Solicit honest feedback from leaders and participants. Make adjustments to the structure, curriculum, or leadership support to strengthen the pathway.
- Multiply: As leaders grow and participants mature, encourage the formation of new groups. Multiplication should be organic and Spirit-led, ensuring that each new group maintains the heart and vision of the discipleship pathway while expanding the church’s capacity to disciple more believers.
Conclusion: Discipleship is Possible in Any Size Church
Regardless of the size of the congregation, every church is fully capable of fulfilling the Great Commission through intentional, Spirit-led discipleship. Small churches, often overlooked in broader conversations about church growth, possess unique strengths that make them a fertile ground for genuine spiritual development. Their close-knit communities foster deeper relationships, greater accountability, and personal care, essential components for effective discipleship.
By embracing small-group discipleship models, small churches can create scalable and reproducible pathways that cultivate mature believers and future leaders. With a clear vision, prayerful dependence on the Holy Spirit, and a commitment to raising leaders from within, even the smallest congregations can experience dynamic spiritual growth and multiplication.
Ultimately, discipleship is not limited by size, resources, or location. It is empowered by obedience to Christ’s call and the transformative work of the Holy Spirit. Because of its unique characteristics, every small church can build disciples who, in turn, make disciples, leaving a lasting impact for the Kingdom of God.
Read Chad’s Blog Post: Self-Control in a Scattered World: The Spirit Brings Clarity and Strength
I would be honored to support you if you feel overwhelmed, unsure, or need encouragement. Overcoming resistance to church change starts with empathy, clear communication, and courageous leadership. I can help! I offer one-on-one coaching for pastors navigating seasons of transition, resistance, or renewal. Please reach out if you’d like to start a conversation.
You are not alone. Continue to lead with faith, love, and the steady guidance of the Holy Spirit.
If you’d like help building a healthy church culture, I’d be delighted to partner with you through coaching or a leadership workshop. Reach out to start the conversation.
Don’t forget to subscribe to the blog for more resources on building a healthy, Spirit-led church. If you enjoyed this post on overcoming resistance to church change, be sure to explore my other related posts. http://www.chadbrodrick.com/blog
Make sure to like and share this post!
Blessings,
Chad
Stay Connected! Facebook, Twitter, Instagram
Chad is available for conferences, workshops, and church events. To book Chad for your next event or to inquire about specific topics, don’t hesitate to get in touch with him. For more information, click the following link: Speaking
Also, Chad is available for personalized coaching sessions and consultations. Click the following link to book with Chad or inquire about our specific coaching and consultation services. Coaching
