Adapted from the M1AG Staff Leadership Development Series, November 10, 2026, Miami First Assembly of God, Miami, Oklahoma.

Introduction: Why Character Matters in Spiritual Leadership

The character of a spiritual leader is one of the most important factors influencing the health, trust, and effectiveness of a church. I’ve worked alongside some incredibly gifted people in ministry. Some were excellent communicators, others were exceptional administrators, and many had a remarkable ability to organize ministries, inspire volunteers, and lead people toward a common vision.

Through those experiences, I have learned that a person’s gifts and abilities can sometimes develop faster than their character. Someone may be a talented preacher, gifted musician, capable administrator, or influential ministry leader, but their effectiveness can be undermined when their personal integrity does not support their public responsibilities.

During our staff leadership development series at Miami First Assembly of God, we began by examining Jesus’ example of servant leadership in Mark 10:42-45. We considered how Christ calls us to use our influence and authority to serve others rather than pursue personal recognition. You can read about it here: Leading Through Serving: The Heart of Biblical Leadership | Session 1

Building upon that foundation, I want to explore another essential aspect of biblical leadership: the character of the person entrusted with responsibility.

Our character determines our leadership’s credibility.

People may initially respect us because of our position, experience, or abilities. However, lasting trust develops when they consistently observe integrity, humility, faithfulness, and spiritual maturity in our lives.

The question every Christian leader must consider is whether our personal character supports the responsibilities God has entrusted to us.

Read 1 Timothy 3:1-7 (ESV).

The apostle Paul wrote this letter to Timothy, who was providing leadership and instruction to the church in Ephesus. Among the challenges Timothy faced was helping establish healthy leadership within the congregation.

In this passage, Paul outlines the qualifications for those who would serve as overseers. These qualifications specifically address the office of overseer, and we should understand them within that biblical context. Nevertheless, the spiritual qualities Paul emphasizes provide valuable instruction for every Christian who carries responsibility and influence.

What stands out to me is how much attention Paul gives to personal character, relationships, spiritual maturity, and reputation.

He speaks of being above reproach, exercising self-control, demonstrating gentleness, faithfully managing personal responsibilities, and maintaining a good reputation outside the church.

These qualities reveal something important about God’s expectations for spiritual leadership.

Spiritual Leadership Flows From Spiritual Maturity

Leadership involves influencing people, providing direction, and helping others accomplish a shared purpose. Within the church, those responsibilities carry an additional spiritual dimension because we are serving Christ and caring for people who belong to Him.

Our responsibility is to represent Jesus faithfully in both our words and our actions.

A leader’s personal character influences how decisions are made, how people are treated, how problems are handled, and how faithfully responsibilities are fulfilled. Over time, these patterns shape the culture of the entire ministry.

For this reason, character development must remain a priority throughout every season of leadership.

1. Spiritual Leadership Begins With Personal Character

Paul begins his description of an overseer by emphasizing the importance of being above reproach. He continues by identifying qualities such as self-control, respectability, hospitality, gentleness, and freedom from the love of money.

Before addressing the work a leader accomplishes, Paul gives considerable attention to how that leader lives.

Being above reproach does not mean that a person has achieved sinless perfection. Every believer has weaknesses and areas where the Holy Spirit continues His transforming work. However, spiritual leaders should pursue lives of integrity that give others no legitimate reason to question their conduct or credibility.

Throughout my ministry, I have seen how quickly leadership trust can weaken when personal character becomes inconsistent. A leader may have years of faithful service, considerable knowledge, and exceptional abilities, yet repeated dishonesty, uncontrolled anger, or careless behavior can damage relationships and undermine confidence. A church leader does not need to use tools to silence people if their private character matches their public conduct.

Character Reveals Itself in Everyday Decisions

For those serving in church leadership, character becomes visible in ordinary circumstances.

How do we respond when someone disagrees with our decisions? What happens when a volunteer fails to meet an expectation? How do we speak about people when they are absent? Are we responsible with confidential information, financial resources, and the responsibilities entrusted to us?

These everyday situations often reveal more about our spiritual maturity than moments when we stand before a congregation.

Proverbs 10:9 (ESV) reminds us that whoever walks in integrity walks securely. A life characterized by honesty and consistency provides a foundation upon which healthy relationships and lasting leadership can develop.

The character we demonstrate in private responsibilities eventually influences the trust people place in our public leadership.

As Christian leaders, we should regularly invite the Holy Spirit to examine our attitudes, motives, and actions. His work within us prepares us to lead others with wisdom and integrity.

2. Spiritual Leadership Requires Consistency Between Our Public and Private Lives

In 1 Timothy 3:4-5, Paul addresses the importance of managing one’s household faithfully. He also emphasizes that an overseer must have a good reputation among those outside the church.

These qualifications reveal that spiritual leadership cannot be separated from personal conduct.

How we live outside the church affects our credibility inside the church. Our family relationships, financial decisions, personal habits, and interactions with others all contribute to the testimony of our lives.

Consider the challenge of showing patience and kindness during a worship service while consistently treating coworkers disrespectfully during the week. Such inconsistency eventually becomes noticeable and can create confusion about the values we claim to represent.

The same principle applies to stewardship. A ministry leader who teaches responsibility must also demonstrate faithfulness in handling resources, completing assignments, and honoring commitments.

Faithfulness in Small Responsibilities

Jesus teaches in Luke 16:10 (ESV) that faithfulness in little things reveals something important about our trustworthiness with greater responsibilities.

For church staff members, that faithfulness may involve maintaining accurate records, arriving prepared for meetings, protecting confidential information, communicating clearly, and following through on commitments.

A ministry director demonstrates integrity by fulfilling promises made to volunteers. An administrative assistant shows faithfulness by handling sensitive information responsibly. A pastor builds trust by treating people with the same respect and care in private conversations that he demonstrates publicly.

While these responsibilities may seem routine, they create an environment where people know they can depend on their leaders.

Consistency builds trust because people know what to expect from our character, regardless of the circumstances.

Our private lives and public responsibilities should reflect the same commitment to following Jesus. When we recognize inconsistencies, the appropriate response is humility, repentance, and a willingness to grow.

3. Spiritual Leadership Requires Continued Spiritual Growth

In 1 Timothy 3:6, Paul warns against appointing a recent convert to the office of overseer. His concern centers on spiritual immaturity and the danger of pride.

This warning reminds us that spiritual maturity develops over time. While a person may possess natural leadership ability, spiritual wisdom requires a growing relationship with God and a willingness to submit to His Word.

One of the dangers experienced leaders face is becoming overly dependent on their experience. After years of serving in ministry, it can become easy to rely on familiar methods, established habits, and personal abilities without maintaining the same level of spiritual dependence that characterized earlier seasons.

Experience certainly offers valuable lessons, but it should never replace our need for prayer, Scripture, accountability, and the Holy Spirit’s guidance.

Regardless of how long we have served, every Christian leader must remain teachable.

Growing Through the Work of the Holy Spirit

Galatians 5:22-23 (ESV) lists the fruit of the Spirit: love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control.

These qualities should become increasingly evident in our lives as we surrender ourselves to the Spirit’s transforming work.

As Pentecostal believers, we recognize our need for the Holy Spirit’s empowerment in ministry. We depend upon Him to guide us, strengthen us, and equip us to accomplish the work God has called us to do. We must also remain attentive to His ongoing work of developing Christlike character within us.

The exercise of spiritual gifts and the development of spiritual fruit should both be welcomed in our lives. A spiritually healthy leader desires to be used by God while becoming increasingly like Jesus.

John 15:4-5 (ESV) reminds us that lasting spiritual fruit comes from abiding in Christ.

We cannot effectively encourage others toward spiritual maturity while continually neglecting our own relationship with Jesus.

Our responsibilities may change, our skills may improve, and our opportunities for leadership may increase, but our need for spiritual growth remains constant.

Practical Application: Examining Our Leadership

When I consider Paul’s instructions to Timothy, I am reminded that leadership development requires more than learning new skills or adopting better organizational methods.

We must continually examine the relationship between our spiritual character and the responsibilities God has entrusted to us.

Are there attitudes that need to change? Have frustration, impatience, pride, or carelessness begun to influence how we treat others? Are we demonstrating the same integrity in our personal lives that we expect from those serving alongside us?

These are important questions for every pastor, church staff member, ministry director, volunteer leader, and Christian who carries responsibility.

The purpose of this examination is spiritual growth. God calls us to repentance, restores us through His grace, and continues to develop Christlike character within us.

My desire for our staff at Miami First Assembly of God is that we become known for our spiritual maturity, genuine relationships, personal integrity, and faithful service to others.

Those qualities help establish a healthy ministry culture and provide a trustworthy foundation for the work God has called us to accomplish.

Conclusion: Becoming Leaders Worth Following

Every leader influences the people around them. Our decisions, attitudes, habits, and conversations communicate what we value and what others can expect from us.

As I reflect on the leaders who have influenced my own life, I recognize that their lasting impact often came through the consistency of their character. Their faithfulness, humility, wisdom, and genuine concern for others demonstrated something about the Jesus they followed.

Those are the qualities I want to keep developing in my own life, and the qualities I hope to encourage in the leaders God has entrusted to my care.

The church needs leaders who are spiritually mature, biblically grounded, emotionally healthy, and committed to living with integrity.

As we grow in our relationship with Christ, the Holy Spirit continues shaping us into people who can lead others with greater wisdom, compassion, and faithfulness.

Ultimately, the character of a spiritual leader should reflect the character of the One they are following.

Weekly Leadership Challenge

I encourage you to take time this week to prayerfully examine your character in light of 1 Timothy 3:1-7.

Identify one quality that needs intentional attention in your life.

Perhaps you need to be more patient when working with others. Maybe you recognize the need for more consistency in keeping commitments, responding to difficult situations, or managing personal responsibilities.

Once you have identified an area for growth, determine one specific action you can take this week.

As you practice that action, ask the Holy Spirit to continue to shape your heart and strengthen your character.

Spiritual growth takes place as we continually respond to God’s Word and cooperate with His transforming work in our lives.

Prayer

Heavenly Father, thank You for calling us to serve You and for entrusting us with opportunities to influence the lives of others. Examine our hearts and reveal any attitudes, habits, or behaviors that need to change. Help us become leaders characterized by integrity, humility, faithfulness, and genuine love for people. Holy Spirit, continue developing Your fruit within us and give us the wisdom to lead in ways that reflect the character of Jesus. Strengthen our personal relationships, guide our decisions, and help us faithfully steward every responsibility You have entrusted to us. In Jesus’ name, amen.


Continue Growing as a Christian Leader

Biblical leadership begins by following Jesus’ example. As we develop our character and strengthen our leadership abilities, we must remember that our calling is to serve the people God has placed in our lives.

I encourage you to continue studying Scripture, developing healthy spiritual habits, and intentionally investing in those you lead.

For more biblical teaching, practical ministry leadership insights, and encouragement for spiritual growth, visit chadbrodrick.com.


Appreciate these blog posts? Buy Pastor Chad a coffee so he can keep writing content! Click below!

Buy Me a Coffee

Logos Bible Study Software

I use Logos Bible Study Software for every sermon, devotional, and Bible study I prepare. Its powerful tools help me go deeper into God’s Word.
👉🏻Discover Logos and start your journey here!


Discover more from Chad A. Brodrick

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.